JK Rowling (And Others) On The ‘Whither Copyright?’ Debate

April 17, 2008

What are we to make of JK Rowling’s impassioned plea on behalf of authors’ copyright?

The creator of the Harry Potter books objects to the publication of “The Harry Potter Lexicon”, an encyclopaedia of wizardry compiled by Steven Vander Ark. Vander Ark, 50, is a devoted Harry Potter fan and has produced the encyclopaedia from a website, which he has operated for several years. The website goes by the same name as his putative book, but Rowling is asking a New York court to impose an injunction preventing its publication.

Vander Ark shed a tear or two in the witness box when asked about his commitment to “the Harry Potter fan club community”, but his emotional disquiet cut no ice with Rowling. Yesterday, as the Telegraph reports, she became rather emotional herself, calling for the court to restrain publication of the lexicon so as not merely to protect her own copyright, but that of authors the world over.

“I believe the flood gates will open,” she is reported to have said, adding, in a rising voice: “Are we the owners of our own work?”

Blade knows one or two writers, and a straw poll of their thoughts suggests that the literati’s sympathy lies with Rowling. But one scribe is worryingly weary.

“It’s OK for Rowling,” she says. “She’s probably a billionaire by now and can afford to hire lawyers to look after her interests. For the average writer, even if their copyright has been infringed going to law is too expensive. And in a few years time, will the Web 2.0 world make policing copyright easier, or harder? It’s going to be a lot harder.”

Is she right? Here are three literary luminaries with their thoughts on a related issue – Google’s quest to digitise every book in the world:

Tracy Chevalier, author of A Girl with A Pearl Earring, says “I’m one of the few writers who would buy a well designed electronic reader. But accessing digitised books online is a very cold way of reading. People also believe that information on the internet should be free, which cheapens our view of knowledge and erodes the value of books.”

Mark Le Fanu, General Secretary of the Society of Authors, perhaps has Dr Johnson’s famous assertion that ‘No man ever wrote, but for money’ in mind when he opines that “Most authors are fretful but excited about the digitising of books. On one level they are worried their texts will be so accessible they will be devalued and their copyright won’t be properly protected. On the other, they like the idea of their books being made more readily available, so long as there is a payment mechanism that rewards them fairly.”But Clare Alexander, president of the Association of Authors’ Agents, says: “Key issues include the royalties authors should be paid and the retrieval of rights once a book is no longer published. We don’t want a world where, just by having a book on a website, a major publishing house can hang onto an enormous cupboard of rights.”

You pays your money and you takes your choice. The verdict in the Rowling case is due in a few weeks. As seems to be the case with her decolletage whenever it is subject to the media glare, it could go either way.manshandbig_468x501.jpg

 

Comments

Please submit comments to Swordplay below.

Seven of the Best Alternative Professionals

August 30, 2010

Susan Casey’s new book, The Wave, is soon to be published. It brilliantly illumines the world of professional big wave surfing, at the same time as exploring the phenomenon of rogue waves (specifically, those which top 100ft).

Suitably inspired, we thought we’d take a look at a different kind of professionalism than is usually to be found on these pages. Those featured in our magnificent seven of alternative professionals may not wear suits for a living, still less spend their time in the boardroom, but they couldn’t do what they do if they weren’t every bit as dedicated, focused, driven and downright professional as those at the helm of a City law firm, finance house or PR company.

1. Laird Hamilton

Hamilton is the star of The Wave, and no wonder. Based on the Hawaiian island of Kauai, the man is a force of nature, a 6″3′ powerhouse who makes big wave surfing look like a walk in the park. But it isn’t. The wave known as Teahupoo, surfed by Hamilton in Tim McKenna’s picture below, is a killer. Only years of focus, training and preparation make Hamilton able to ride this wave with such aplomb.

2. Danny Way

Warning: do not watch this footage if you are afraid of heights (and squeamish). American skateboarding star Danny Way has been rebuilt more times than the bionic man. He’s also made a small fortune from a sport so often wrongly derided as ‘for kids’. Definitely not one for a suit and tie, Way nevertheless deserves respect – as much as he would appear to need a permanent personal medical staff.

3. Shane McConkey

Professional skier Shane McConkey died in March 2009 while skiing in the Dolomite Mountains in Italy. His death robbed the world of extreme sports of an athlete known for combining BASE jumping with skiing, as seen in such feats as skiing into a BASE jump off the Eiger. RIP.

4. Shaun White

There are those who say that White, snowboarder extraordinaire, has the kind of hair that is inimical to success. We say, like Forbes magazine, that if White earned $9 million from his endorsements in 2008 alone, what’s he worth now? We also say: don’t try what White does at home. Or anywhere, really.

5. DannyMacaskill

If BMX riding is jejune, does it matter? Not to Macaskill, a man who’s worth a lot of money thanks to his remarkable ability on a bike.

6. Lynn Hill

There are rock climbers, and there’s Detroit-born Lynn Hill, the woman who made the first free ascent of the infamous Nose Route on El Capitan in Yosemite Valley. Currently sponsored by the Patagonia gear and clothing company, Hill has done it all, taking phenomenal risks in the pursuit of her calling. Take a look at the intensity of her gaze: this woman would have been a genius at whatever she’d chosen to do.

7. Dallas Friday

She has the best name of any sportsperson, ever. She also looks pretty good, too, and is even better at her chosen discipline, wakeboarding. And discipline is the name of the game: as with everyone here, however outre their worlds, however extreme their sports, if they weren’t disciplined they’d not only be impoverished but also, quite possibly, dead. Respect.

Hats off to the News of the World

August 30, 2010

Fantastic sting by the News of the World, whose legendary undercover reporter, Mazher Mahmood, has pierced the heart of some disgraceful match-fixing in professional cricket. Hats off, yet again, to Mahmood, but, strangely, we feel slightly sorry for him. Will he ever be able to retire into the sun and live a normal life? Somehow we rather doubt it.

Pictured: something which is decidedly not cricket.

Judge Dread, truly dread

August 24, 2010

An Englishman’s home is his castle. This ancient tenet of English society means that when a burglar breaks into an Englishman’s home (or castle), the homeowner, or feudal Lord, is entitled to defy him. The tools of defiance are many and varied but include diplomacy (“isn’t it past your bedtime?”), wheedling (“please, my good fellow, won’t you go away?”), lies (“see that castle across the street? It’s full of gold bullion”) and weaponry (“is that a nuclear missile in my pocket, and why aren’t you terrified to see me?”).

This last, however, causes problems. When a homeowner, eager to defend his castle, shoots a burglar, all hell breaks loose. Tabloid hacks break out in sweats as they find themselves compelled to blame European laws and the politically correct for daring to wonder whether such force was necessary when, really, all that is in issue is whether shooting dead an intruder was proportionate to the perceived threat and context.

In the US, this question was recently answered in the affirmative by the excellently named Judge Carlisle Overstreet. The 65-year-old judge shot and killed an unarmed bandana-wearing burglar after the man broke into his home and started coming upstairs. According to the estimable Legal Blog Watch, the dead burglar, John Howard Jr. (who, says the Augusta Chronicle, delighted in the nickname ‘Killa’), was one of two men who broke into the judge’s house in the early hours of the morning. The other, William Omar Jacobs, turned himself in and was denied bail.

This sorry or inspirational tale begs a question. If it had happened here, would it be the first time in recorded history that a judge had killed a burglar? In fact, is this unprecedented across the pond, too? And more to the point, if anyone says the judge acted disproportionately and that he really shouldn’t be canonized, are they politically correct stooges from a morally abased, utterly bankrupt European superstate (or something like that: we confess that tabloidese eludes us)?

Pictured: a judge says “Clint Eastwood isn’t the only one who likes large handguns.” But note: she’s not Carlisle Overstreet.